Skip to main content

How did you find that bug? Are we sitting comfortably, then I'll begin.


How did you find that bug? - They asked with a sort of puzzled "he dun't thunk like uz" look on their faces. An expression that suggested they were unsure whether to commend the discovery or gather their pitchforks and organise a well overdue witch burning.

Likewise, I now knew why they needed me. The team members were genuinely hard working people trying to build something new and exciting. But they lacked one thing, someone exploring & asking questions - trying to find out new things about their application. Exploring is literally a step into the unknown, and that can be uncomfortable for those not experienced in how to do it well.

Related image
Exploring is literally a step into the unknown.
So how did I find that bug? It's easy to tell a story of how I tried that particular input value because... Paragraph 3 of v4.6 of the requirements document stated that the user shall indeed on occasion X given input Y in Chrome v62 do... Or spout some other overly verbose explanation of why that broken 'scenario' came to be valid. 

But I wouldn't be answering their question, and I wouldn't be telling the truth. The truth of how I (and other testers) do this is harder to remember. But having a better idea of how you got there is going to help you get there again.

Let's take a trivial example. A few years ago, working on a new editorial system for a financial news organisation: I discovered that entering a double quote character into the content search feature caused it to crash. Even worse it returned no results (But it didn't fail to provide the users with a nasty technical error message). This had not been noticed before, yet many tests had been written and run. They had more acceptance tests than they could run in a night.

I had not examined requirements documentation for that feature. I had not perused the Acceptance Criteria for the Search feature. I had not reviewed the unreliable test automation. What I did was speak to the team and then type some quoted text into the search form. I had thought that the search should behave like Google, whereby if you include text in quotes - it will search for an exact match to that string of characters. I was interested to see what happened.

I did not know whether the search should support this sort of exact phrase matching. But I was exploring. I knew 'searches' [in my experience] worked like this - so I decided to check if this one did. This was the first step in a series of related tests that allowed me and my colleagues to uncover many more issues with the search feature.

When a team is focused on short-term delivery goals they can lose sight of the features not listed right in front of them. You need someone to question, someone to explore someone to point out that crashing when an editor uses a quote is sub-optimal. That's what I do at Investigating Software.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What possible use could Gen AI be to me? (Part 1)

There’s a great scene in the Simpsons where the Monorail salesman comes to town and everyone (except Lisa of course) is quickly entranced by Monorail fever… He has an answer for every question and guess what? The Monorail will solve all the problems… somehow. The hype around Generative AI can seem a bit like that, and like Monorail-guy the sales-guy’s assure you Gen AI will solve all your problems - but can be pretty vague on the “how” part of the answer. So I’m going to provide a few short guides into how Generative (& other forms of AI) Artificial Intelligence can help you and your team. I’ll pitch the technical level differently for each one, and we’ll start with something fairly not technical: Custom Chatbots. ChatBots these days have evolved from the crude web sales tools of ten years ago, designed to hoover up leads for the sales team. They can now provide informative answers to questions based on documents or websites. If we take the most famous: Chat GPT 4. If we ignore the
Post a Comment
Read more

Is your ChatBot actually using your data?

 In 316 AD Emperor Constantine issued a new coin,  there's nothing too unique about that in itself. But this coin is significant due to its pagan/roman religious symbols. Why is this odd? Constantine had converted himself, and probably with little consultation -  his empire to Christianity, years before. Yet the coin shows the emperor and the (pagan) sun god Sol.  Looks Legit! While this seems out of place, to us (1700 years later), it's not entirely surprising. Constantine and his people had followed different, older gods for centuries. The people would have been raised and taught the old pagan stories, and when presented with a new narrative it's not surprising they borrowed from and felt comfortable with both. I've seen much the same behaviour with Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT. You can provide them with fresh new data, from your own documents, but what's to stop it from listening to its old training instead?  You could spend a lot of time collating,
Post a Comment
Read more

Can Gen-AI understand Payments?

When it comes to rolling out updates to large complex banking systems, things can get messy quickly. Of course, the holy grail is to have each subsystem work well independently and to do some form of Pact or contract testing – reducing the complex and painful integration work. But nonetheless – at some point you are going to need to see if the dog and the pony can do their show together – and its generally better to do that in a way that doesn’t make millions of pounds of transactions fail – in a highly public manner, in production.  (This post is based on my recent lightning talk at  PyData London ) For the last few years, I’ve worked in the world of high value, real time and cross border payments, And one of the sticking points in bank [software] integration is message generation. A lot of time is spent dreaming up and creating those messages, then maintaining what you have just built. The world of payments runs on messages, these days they are often XML messages – and they can be pa
Post a Comment
Read more